Compa_Mighty, I agree that those games are maybe better, but they kinda aren't PC games. Either way, the best of any games ever ever is Ocarina of Time, no doubt.
NIB, I'll agree with you that it is a very good game, hell I've played on it loads too, but its just lacking depth really, bit of a WYSIWYG game. Nick cars, waste some Crips (lol) and beating up old ladies is great fun, but that alone isn't enough too keep you permanently going back for more, which I guess is how a truly great game is defined. As for perfection, well, less said the better.
Oh and trigger happy Americans..... killing more of our boys in Iraq than Saddam's lot is pretty crap.
In a race between a rock and a pig,
don't varnish your clams.