Playability: 2
Uh there is no way you will be able to play this scenario.
Balance: 2
Oh yeah lots of Balance. This map has waaay too many units and lags horribly.
Creativity: 4
The Norse titans for Mountian trolls was a good idea and the Automation for the Citadel Guard was a nice touch.
Map Design: 2
This does not look like Minas Tirith at all.
Story/Instructions: 3
Nothing Really to say here.
Additional Comments:
I am so sick of these scenarios. There is no skill whatsoever. People who think they are experts at Lord of the Rings from seeing the Movies Peter Jackson made are missing alot. You have probably not read the books and didn't include Grond.
Argh!!!!
You all make "Lord of the rings" Scenarios that are just a bunch of units and lag.
I'm sorry I said that you stole thinkb4ublink's Minas Tirith I opened the wrong file.
Lexus_Reloaded File Author
Posted on 01/05/04 @ 12:21 PM
I did read the books and if you wait for 2 minutes Grond will come and destoy the Gate. Then after 8 minutes will Rohan come.
Lexus_Reloaded File Author
Posted on 01/05/04 @ 03:33 PM
Hey Fenris. Please tell me what to do to make this map look like the real Minas Tirith.
Fenris77
Posted on 01/05/04 @ 06:46 PM
I think if you add height to each level and use more walls of troy instead of reguler walls it would look much better.
As for using only Murmillo I think you should add differnt units such as hoplites, ulfsarks and spearman cuz orcs look differnt and seeing 1000 murmillo doesn't look right.
You really captured the massiveness of the battle I think if you spend another day on it I could give you a 5.0 :).
[Edited on 01/05/04 @ 06:46 PM]
Treebeard III
Posted on 01/05/04 @ 11:33 PM
Prolem with making minas tirith in aom is that the cliffs cant go high enough
Treebeard III
Posted on 01/05/04 @ 11:36 PM
My Campaign will also include music and dialog from the lord of the rings movies
Lexus_Reloaded File Author
Posted on 01/06/04 @ 11:31 AM
Thanks. I'm really going to use that help in my upgraded version.
Lord_Elrond
Posted on 01/08/04 @ 08:18 AM
Hi
I myself am a big lord of the rings fan, from reading the books several times... Its nice to see sum people make real effort towards some really cool scenarios. I've built the Battle for Middle Earth version 3, which i don't think many people understand cos its not really lord of the rings, but the 1500 year period beforehand concernin the fall of gondor...
I will have a few critiscims:
Put Minas Tirith in the West... in the book, Mordor is in the East (not the South as a lot of people seem to think).
Remembers, its a city!!. Not just walls and walls and walls
Denethors Pyre looks cool :D
The architecture should be more classical, greek rather than egyptian
Erm... leave the big cliffy thing out
Regards
Lord_Elrond / Jonno
chow
Posted on 01/10/04 @ 05:08 PM
hey ppl
i made a minas tirth too! and battle at mordor gate. im gonna post it in a couple of hours! rate mine!