Playability: 1
What can I say? It cannot be played at all, there simply is nothing on the map to play with.
Balance: 1
The 'game' ends after some 10 seconds with an automatic victory.
Creativity: 1
No triggers, no story, no nothing. Not even a single unit!
Map Design: 1
Some Troyan Walls on some cliffs, five or six buildings – that's it. That's not even enough to be used as a basis for someone to build his own scenario. It would save him what - five minutes? The map is huge (2000x2000), and it's 99% empty.
Story/Instructions: 1
There are none.
Additional Comments:
The only reason I bothered to put my comments in writing is to save potential downloaders some frustration. Even people who jump on everything even remotely connected to LotR should think twice here. It probably took me more time to write up my comments than it took the designer to create his map.
Oh, and before someone thinks about removing this one-sentence-per-point review, please have a look at the 'scenario' first. There really is not more to say!