Loving made many mistakes (wasting resources on walls, building slingers despite BGM having no archers, failing to ensure a steady and sufficient supply of gold, not building enough spearmen and axeman, etc) but BGM's gameplay overall was really, really poor. His attempted rush was decent, but he didn't have the balls to finish Loving off so he fled, allowing Loving some time to turtle. At one point, as Loving's army was approaching BGM's main village, BMG's wood and gold resources were approaching 4000 apiece, yet his population was 75/60 and his army almost nonexistent. And all of his towers completely unguarded. It was nice when Loving f i n a l l y went on the aggressive (sure took ya long enough) and destroyed BGM, he deserved it.