Balance: 1
Your big army vs two groups of orcs? come on!
Creativity: 3
Well even though I have seen many LOTR scenarios, Gondor was awsome! coverd in eyecandy!
Map Design: 5
Minas Tirith was really really good dude! The catapults were really impressive on how you placed them!)
Story/Instructions: 3
Not much. Sit back and watch the orcs die
Additional Comments:
Make the orcs a lot stronger and alot more of them!
Hikari (id: echowinds)
Posted on 01/05/06 @ 05:31 AM
"sorry but basicly he told me it was shit"
Maybe you should take some of his advices and improve on it?
Ulrichomega
Posted on 01/15/06 @ 12:52 PM
Playability: 1
Very easy. You don't really have to do anything, I just sent out my villagers and such to kill them and it worked.
Balance: 1
40 orcs vs. 20 cavalry and some hoplites with massive towers and catapults, hmm... Triple the amount of orcs, take away the villagers, and decrease the amount of Rohirrim.
Creativity: 1
Minas Tirith, well, at least it wasn't Helms Deep. THat scenario has been done to death, literally.
Map Design: 3
A little to much on the city, and not enough on the rest of the map. If you had gone over the rest of the map with the roughen tool, then it would have been much better.
Story/Instructions: 1
No instructions, but it really has no nead for them, mainly because the orcs come at you as soon as the battle starts.
Additional Comments:
None
[Edited on 01/19/06 @ 06:12 PM]
Leinadarcher
Posted on 01/22/06 @ 07:33 AM
Jonathon sounds like a wannabe mod xD.
But also you shouldn't have taken the review that badly...
lotrmaster1234hi
Posted on 12/01/06 @ 08:02 AM
This is by far the best Minas Tirith I have ever seen. I'm not gonna lie to you, there are not at all enough Orcs in it, and there is no way that you can be defeated in this level. But if I were to use it in my upcoming campaign The Seige At Minas Tirith, I can make it better?
Aliblabla1942
Posted on 12/03/06 @ 07:49 AM
What heck???? If you set it to Hades, your guys will respawn as shades back in the temple. I know this scenario sucks in everything BUT map design, which is around 4 from my view, but I'm pretty sure THAT detracts from the score. NOTE to all you guys: The Walls are not supposed to have any towers, and the trebbies are on the second and third levels.