Well, at first it's a nice idea. Secondly, it's nice and small, resonable presentation and such, and thirdly, it has some valuable basic information.
I have some critics too: this kind of camp looks nice (I think), but wouldn't have very much of a function in the game. Maybe Atlanteans don't fit in the game, maybe the creator has a different opinion than you about the pig. I would extend it a bit if I were you (maybe some suggestions about the combination of land types?), and add some instructions for a Norse, Egyptian and/or Greek camp as well.
[Edited on 08/31/06 @ 10:29 AM]
Posted on 08/31/06 @ 09:59 PM
Sorry man but the guide was not very useful. It didnt explain what terrain types to use depending on if the camps in snow, egyptian or whatever. The picture u put in didnt really look that great. It was flat very small and u only had 1 texture and a camp usually doesnt have a city terrain under it. Also in the guide you said to use many terrains to make it look realistic. This is true but this would be more GrassA mixed with GrassB and GrassDirt50 or such. Not the 1 terrain you showed in the picture. This could've a much better guide and sorry for the low rating.
Posted on 09/10/06 @ 05:45 PM
This seemed kinda rushed... The screenshot you used wasn't very good... I like the idea and it would help quite a few people, so I say that you should try again. Take your time on it and expand on your ideas. Also, the terrain mizing and diffrent civilization camp types ideas are good so I think you should try to work on those too. For your first guide, it's pretty good. Just take the reveiws seriously and you'll be making good guides in no time.