I gave this a 2 because while it isn't terrible, It's not something I'd download. When downloading it came with three text files to read which didn't really explain anything except that I shouldn't edit the map. Once I ran the scenario I noticed that cinematic mode was not used and nothing happened except repeated invocation of Meteor on some Guardians and Minions. Very nice camera movements though.
Again, it's not terrible, but many designers make stuff like this in their free time, just to have fun blowing stuff up. This isn't something new brought to the table.
[Edited on 03/09/07 @ 08:55 AM]
Posted on 03/10/07 @ 04:31 AM
As much as i like to see meteors blowing up stuff, i have to give this a 1.5. This is ok, but it needs much improvements, there was nothing but flat terrain and no embellishments. I have given you half a point for the nice trigger works and the camera tracks. I suggest you make elevation and map design look more attractive to the human eye. ;)
You know thoose arcuses? You don't need them there, all you need to do is turn victory conditions off. That way you don't have to worry about players having nothing on the map but, still not lose.