Playability: 4
It was a nice game of supremecy, playable, i went through it with my friends, we all enjoyed it.
Balance: 4
The scenario wasn't that all balanced, due to the fact that it was 1v3, however the defender and the attacker have their ups and downs, also when the game starts the defender theoretically is the attacker -.-''
Creativity: 5
Loved the gate lol, very creative, however, in the middle of playing it kinda had that feeling that i was playing LOTR-Helms Deep again, but at least it doesn't lag. ^.^
Map Design: 3
The reason why you received a three for this part of the review is because, (no offense) it wasn't that appealing. The eye-candy of the castle could obviously need some touching up. Take a look at the Helms Deep maps, the forts in there are quite well made.
Story/Instructions: 3
Wasn't very clear, the only rushing in my mind when playing as a host is defend my fort... defend my fort... a bit repetitive after a few hours of playing it. Instructions weren't that clear, mabe creating a read-me to go with the download or a clear opening cinematic. When the scenario started we were given the feeling that we just jumped into the wilderness with a bad of chips and flashlight and told to survive 20 days.
Additional Comments:
A enjoyable scenario, fit for players who tend to play random map games, instead of escapes, RPGs, and all other maps. I recomend downloading it and play it with your friends.