This map is so easy to learn and play with, which is why this get's a pretty good 4. It's just like any other Sims map, and you only need simple instructions to learn how to play. The only thing that would be puzzling is the "stand on the blue pad" method. Some newbies might not quite understand it.
Everyone (Except the Mayor) starts out with a villager, and a good amount of gold; except Player 2. There's also the fact that it's so easy to buy powerful monsters, and then destroy your foes quickly. It's almost as unbalanced as the Guardian.
A cheap copy of Sims Irktropolis. No, even worse. You copied this from Sims Irk VFlame. Almost everything was seen before in Irk VFlame, which is why you get a measly 1 for creativity.
Next time, try not to edit maps please.
Map Design: 2
You said the eyecandy was amazing and unbelievable; that's not true. There's no eyecandy anywhere, and you removed the decent looking Raider Mart as well as doing bad things to the terrain. The arena looks like it was messed up by a baby. I don't like it. 2.
There's no story to this, which is why it only get's a three, however, the instructions are very clear; even though it wasn't you that made the instructions. Did pretty well on this one (I guess)
Please try not to edit maps. Yes, I know that everyone started off like that, but editing maps and putting them up on sites isn't a very good idea. If you are new to triggers, you could start a smaller map, eitherway, please don't copy other maps and ruin them.