scragins
Heretic of December
posted 24 September 2014 10:12 AM
EDT (US)
331 / 401
I think Ash is scum because;
1. He has been very persistent with the idea that I could have been a tracker SK. Then again he was somewhat persistent with the idea that Baske is a SK, both times more so than the other players.
2. He has suggested who the cop (which we don't have should target) and when he did this he suggested town players. This would have wasted the cops time helping scum by not letting them get caught.
3.Early on in the game he assumed there were multiple power roles and wanted me reveal who had targeted Herr on night 0. This was not what I believed and he had no supporting evidence, he then ignored my question when I asked him why he believed there were numerous power roles, he has now answered. Making assumptions based on flawed reasoning is common scum play as it allows false assumptions to be made and this also revealed who the town only 2 power roles were.
4.Numerous times Ash has used 'reasoning' along the lines of "because I'm usually right". Again this is use of poor reasoning which is common scum behavior.
5. He uses little reasoning to attempt to verify players instead he only chooses to attack players, keeping potential lynch targets available.
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 27 September 2014 07:34 AM
EDT (US)
336 / 401
I targeted Ash but failed again.
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 28 September 2014 08:05 PM
EDT (US)
338 / 401
I do not know what caused me to fail. However I do know that if they have or use no action on the night I will be informed of that, so that is not the cause of me failing.
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 29 September 2014 08:35 PM
EDT (US)
341 / 401
The extra kill clears Baske in my eyes so I thought he was an honest survivor. The more he went on about there being 2 mafia still alive does to me suggest he must be mafia though as 2 mafia + survivor would result in 50% being scum and would have done so with the past few days if you factor in scum players who have died they have had 50% for the past 2 days or so and if that is the case I would have expected them to push more for a mislynch and get the game over. In other words for there to be 2 mafia members it is most likely Baske is one of them and not intact a survivor.
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 29 September 2014 08:37 PM
EDT (US)
342 / 401
I would in particular like to know what Baske and Ninja thought about the points I raised against Ash as they did ask for a summary on them and so for have not commented on it.
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 29 September 2014 08:38 PM
EDT (US)
343 / 401
Sorry about the third post but Mozzy was also asked to summarize his points and has not done so yet, I would like to know if they are the same as mine or not.
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 30 September 2014 06:38 AM
EDT (US)
349 / 401
What I believe normally happens is that a survivor adds to the number of members a mafia faction has.
Blatant could you please clarify how a survivor affects the winning conditions of the game.