Excelsior
Mortal
posted 06 August 2014 07:50 AM
EDT (US)
51 / 401
@Accusers: I sincerely made a mistake when I thought I was an actual idol. I apologize. However, that really does seem to be the only basis of your questions, as your logic fails to include the fact that if I had known that I was actually a fish, I would have paraphrased my claim differently.
My second mistake was feeling guilty that I would be gone over the weekend, and I thought the forum would be more active. Thus I felt guilty for my absence.
BUT, in most other mafia games I play, I usually glean usual info by claiming early and bumbling on it, as you learn who are your friends and who is willing to jump on a mistake, regardless of whether its scummy or not. If I take long enough about it, I can sometimes help guide the lynch to a straight-up mafia on Day 1. So, no, Yeeb, I don’t feel it was OMGUS, although on second thought I did retract my request for Ash, as I think I have a feel for why he wanted my claim.
Excelsior
Mortal
posted 06 August 2014 07:59 AM
EDT (US)
52 / 401
@Scragins: Another point about the names is that powder-black sturgeon, blue parrotfish, blue spotted stingray, and golden damselfish all have colors in their names, while the rest of us do not. But, if you add in your research about the native oceans, I might be wrong regarding WRP.
In any case, I don’t think we need to rely on Yeeb’s opinion of Alex, as your own conclusion puts those two in the outs (If I understood you correctly).
Excelsior
Mortal
posted 06 August 2014 08:09 AM
EDT (US)
53 / 401
@Scragins: I wasn’t given any flavor that made me believe I was anything. All I got was the Moorish Idol part, and my role and faction sentence, and that was it.
If I actually had flavor, I would not have launched off into the now embarrassing mistake of calling myself a god when I was a fish.
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 09 August 2014 06:35 AM
EDT (US)
65 / 401
Yeeb do you have a list of all claims so far?
scragins
Heretic of December
posted 10 August 2014 07:34 AM
EDT (US)
70 / 401
Well as we are only 2 names away I think we should get them before we make a decision on what we do next, Yeeb may still have some lead to follow on name claims.
Excelsior
Mortal
posted 12 August 2014 12:40 PM
EDT (US)
72 / 401
I am hoping Blatant didn't make the roles per name-claim obvious....
Excelsior
Mortal
posted 12 August 2014 03:53 PM
EDT (US)
75 / 401
......You have a better plan?
It is Day 1. The only thing we currently have is discussion, with the hope that something useful comes up. If you have a better avenue of discussion, I believe the game is ripe for it. (Although with only Ash's nameclaim left, we might as well close that road while we're on it.)