This is a map of middle earth from the book THE LORD OF THE RINGS. This is the first thing I have ever submitted, though I have made many other scenarios. This is just a map, so you can add your own units or cinematics. Feel free to use this in any scenario you might make and submit it. If you like it or if you experience any problems, contact me at cmw2@cox.net.
Thank you
Marshall
Playability: 3
I gave the playability a three because you didn't intend for it to be used to play - yet, but it could potentally be a great scnario to play.
Balance: 3
The balance isn't actually very good because as i pointed out already you didn't intend for it to be played on, however, the forces of each player are a fair representation as they are in the movie/book.
Creativity: 3
I couldn't give you top marks for this because it's not actually your idea (obviously) but many people have tried to make a map such as yours and yours is the best i've seen so far.
Map Design: 4
The map is the only aspect i can really mark because that's all it really is, you did a great job making it even though it doesn't match that of the actual middle earth map. Nice one.
Story/Instructions: 1
Again I have to say i can't give this a good rating because you only made this as a map, but i'm sure if you'd made this as a proper scenario and made some changes it would score a better mark right here.
Additional Comments:
Though it's not entirely correct and you can't play without making your own changes to it, this an excellent map! download it now! make your own changes or just admire the work!