Playability: 4
This is easy to play but the speed on build and research is WAY too fast. I was murdering this guy and he made too many men in his base cut it down. So dont put soo much speed on it.
Balance: 3
Good Balance here. you got everything in the right proportions for a 3 just try to make it much better for it to get a 4 or even a 5.
Creativity: 3
Many Many sea maps have been made were you fight. This is different though as you get men popping up. That was a good idea but try think of something more creative.
Map Design: 2
Not much eye candy. All you put was 2 islands which were in bade locations. 1 between player 2 and 4 i believe and the other in the middle. Try puttin trees, fish, whales anything to make it look nicer.
Story/Instructions: 2
NOT really any story here. Basically fight till death. so maybe you could put a story line in like this: "Many People Have Tried To Claim This Sea As It Contains A Rich Wealth".
Additional Comments: Plus i use Bellerophon and Ouranos in my maps. Its ok if you use Bellerophon cause i use two things to make it more fun. And for everyone who wants to know i came to more than 3 lines in the writing part.